Amy Goldschlager Reviews That Inevitable Victorian Thing Audiobook by E.K. Johnston
That Inevitable Victorian Thing, E.K. Johnston; Katherine Kellgren, narrator (Listening Library, $25.00, digital download, 8.5 hr., unabridged) October 2017.
This thoughtful yet frothy confection is set in an alternate future that developed when Queen Victoria rejected the repressive Kensington system so definitively that her daughter, not her son, succeeded her, and that heir fostered the belief that marrying among the various peoples of the Empire would strengthen it. And it worked, beautifully. Unfortunately, the United States rejected such mixing, and as such, it’s failing.
As soon as Helena Marcus finishes her Toronto debut season, August Callaghan plans to marry her. During her season, Helena meets Margaret Sandwich, and the two girls become close friends. But August has a secret: he’s been paying off American pirates to keep his family’s lumber ships safe, engendering a dangerous and illegal cycle of extortion. And Margaret has a secret: She’s actually Princess Victoria-Margaret, heir to the throne of the British Empire. And Helena also has a secret, albeit recently discovered. She is intersex; although she presents as female and thinks of herself as female, she is genetically male. August fears his legal trouble will prevent him from making an honest proposal. Helena fears her inability to bear August children will prevent her from accepting his proposal. And Margaret, who has always known her duty to marry well, fears she’s beginning to fall in love with Helena….
Katherine Kellgren’s elegant voice is beautifully suited to this British-Canadian comedy of manners; as always, she creates an atmosphere of refined culture that lends us all more grace simply by listening. She evokes various social classes through the accents she uses, and there’s even a wonderfully nuanced difference between incognito Margaret vs. Victoria-Margaret giving orders as a princess.
This is an extraordinarily sweet romance that is sure to please everyone, and is a non-preachy answer for those seeking something beyond the usual cis-het fare. Also, there’s a lot to like about this future; I almost wish I lived there.
This review and more like it in the January 2018 issue of Locus.