Locus Online



2000 Letters Archive


Send us your letters! Locus Online has more room than the magazine for letters. They can be about Locus or the SF field in general.


March 2001

Letters on this page
Posted 6 March:

Note: Return e-mail addresses will be posted only if you include it in your closing, or your subject matter specifically requests some sort of response; otherwise it will be omitted.

Dear Locus,
     I am writing to you to learn if you have any information concerning the whereabouts of Kenneth C. Flint, author of Riders of the Sidhe and other novels of ancient Irish legends. His last novel was The Darkening Flood, which appeared in 1995. Is Mr. Flint dead or has he just stopped writing? Does anyone know?

Arthur L. Goodwin
5 March 2001

Dear Locus,
     I'm an avid reader of publications such as Locus and Science Fiction Chronicle. For years I've wondered why reviews are written that can go on forever about the story in a particular book but not one mention of the cover art or cover artist. At most all I ever see is a line that says "cover by artist name" and that's about it.
     When I think of the hours spent trying to get a cover created which is the first thing buyers see on the shelf, I feel bad for the artists who go largely unknown and unrecognized by the general book-buying public. Especially when not even a brief mention is ever made in the often lengthy book reviews.
     Maybe they should start selling all books in plain brown covers with just the title and the author's name on it. It would make for incredibly boring looking book stores but at least the publishers, editors and authors wouldn't have to worry about giving any credit to the artists.

Robert Hobbs
23 Feb 2001

[ It's a good question -- but the main, very simple, reason is that book reviewers usually only see advance galleys, i.e. paperbound versions of books with all the text -- but not the cover art. Another reason is that the authors of books rarely have control of or input to the selection of the cover art, and in a discussion of the cover art in a book review it would be difficult to avoid judging whether the art was suitable or accurate -- and this could be unfair to the author. Artists get their due in books devoted to their art, such as are covered in Karen Haber's occasional column in Locus, which has recently looked at collections of art by Frank Kelly Freas, Chris Moore, Rowena Morrill, John Harris, Julie Bell, and others.
--ed. ]

Dear Locus,
     I recently tried to find an all-time Sci-Fi Bestseller list, and there doesn't seem to be one.
     I've asked a number of reasonably literate people, and the opinions vary widely. (Bradbury's Fahrenheit 451, Herbert's Dune, Heinlein's Stranger In A Strange Land, and the list goes on.)
     Do you folks know of a source on this? Maybe it could be another column for you.

Clint Bright
5 March 2001

[ Offhand, I'd guess the all-time bestselling SF book is... L. Ron Hubbard's Battlefield Earth. But that's a whole 'nother story. No, Locus doesn't know of any authoritative list such as you're looking for. Individual publishers probably have ranking of their own books, but a problem with books like those by Bradbury, Herbert, and Heinlein is that they have changed publishers over the years, so no single source could offer complete, all-time sales figures.
--ed. ]


© 2001 by Locus Publications. All rights reserved.