| | 2007 |
| SF/FANTASY/HORROR: | Izzy and Eve, Neal Drinnan
|
| | 2006 |
| SF/FANTASY/HORROR: | Daughters of an Emerald Dusk, Katherine V. Forrest
|
| | 2005 |
| PIONEER AWARD: | Samuel R. Delany
|
| SF/FANTASY/HORROR: | The Ordinary, Jim Grimsley
|
| | 2004 |
| SF/FANTASY/HORROR: | Necrologue, Helen Sandler
|
| | 2003 |
| SF/FANTASY/HORROR: | Queer Fear II, Michael Rowe, ed.
|
| | 2002 |
| SF/FANTASY/HORROR: | Point of Dreams, Melissa Scott & Lisa A. Barnett
|
| | 2001 |
| SF/FANTASY/HORROR: | Kirith Kirin, Jim Grimsley
|
| | 2000 |
| SF/FANTASY: | Minions of the Moon, Richard Bowes
|
| | 1999 |
| SF/FANTASY (tie): | Bending the Landscape: Science Fiction, Nicola Griffith & Stephen Pagel, eds.
|
| SF/FANTASY (tie): | Galilee, Clive Barker
|
| | 1998 |
| SF/FANTASY: | Bending the Landscape: Fantasy, Nicola Griffith & Stephen Pagel, eds.
|
| | 1997 |
| SF/FANTASY: | Sacrament, Clive Barker
|
| | 1996 |
| SF/FANTASY (tie): | Slow River, Nicola Griffith
|
| SF/FANTASY (tie): | Shadow Man, Melissa Scott
|
| | 1995 |
| SF/FANTASY: | Trouble and Her Friends, Melissa Scott
|
| | 1994 |
| SF/FANTASY: | The Fifth Sacred Thing, Starhawk
|
| | 1993 |
| LIFETIME AWARD: | Samuel R. Delany
|
| GAY MEN'S SF/FANTASY: | China Mountain Zhang, Maureen F. McHugh
|
| LESBIAN SF/FANTASY: | Ammonite, Nicola Griffith
|
| | 1992 |
| GAY MEN'S SF/FANTASY: | The Dark Beyond the Stars, Frank M. Robinson
|
| LESBIAN SF/FANTASY: | The Gilda Stories, Jewelle Gomez
|
| | 1991 |
| GAY MEN'S SF/FANTASY (tie): | Magic's Price, Mercedes Lackey
|
| GAY MEN'S SF/FANTASY (tie): | Secret Matter, Toby Johnson
|
| LESBIAN SF/FANTASY: | Gossamer Axe, Gačl Baudino
|
| | 1990 |
| GAY MEN'S SF/FANTASY: | Somewhere in the Night, Jeffrey N. McMahan, ed.
|
| LESBIAN SF/FANTASY: | What Did Miss Darlington See?: An Anthology of Feminist Supernatural Fiction, Jessica Amanda Salmonson, ed.
|
| | 1989 |
| GAY MEN'S SF/FANTASY: | Goldenboy, Michael Nava
|
| LESBIAN MYSTERY/SF NOVEL: | Skiptrace, Antoinette Azolakov
|